The Jewish Origins of Islam (Talmudic Dilemma walkthrough)

Описание: Going through the Talmudic Dilemma with some examples from the Talmud.

This is a continuation of the Islamic Dilemma argument. It is another piece of the puzzle which both strengthens the Islamic Dilemma while also disproving Islam in a different way. They complement each other and both show that Islam has to be false.

The Quran claims it is God’s direct, unique revelation given only through prophets (Surah 42:51; Surah 4:163–165), and Mohammad is presented as the final prophet (33:40). Yet large, specific passages in the Quran closely parallel rabbinic Midrash and Talmudic material (Mishnah ~200 AD; Gemara 300–500 AD) that was circulating in late antiquity.

That creates a dilemma: either God revealed truth through Jewish rabbis who were not prophets for centuries — which contradicts the Quran’s own doctrine — or Mohammad heard and incorporated human Jewish and Christian material and presented it as divine revelation. The simplest, historically coherent explanation is the latter: the Quran contains human-sourced material. Which undermines the claim that the Quran is wholly divine and inimitable.

FULL TALMUDIC DILEMMA ARGUMENT HERE:
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Y...

SLIDES HERE:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1iF_2...

Defending A Lion with Chris Harvey
===========================
Check out my website here:
https://defendingalion.com/
===========================
Social Links:
➡︎Twitter: https://x.com/DefendingALion
➡︎Facebook:   / 100090811616732  
➡︎TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@defendingalio...
➡︎Instagram:   / defendingalionministries  
===========================

#DefendingALion #christianity #jesus #god #bible #messiah #isalm #talmud