Super Catchiest Guitar Intro | Tool's Culling Voices | Fear Inoculum

Описание: When songs are about a specific issue for a specific individual, they are either from pure motivation (10,000 Days, Jambi) or comically base (Stinkfist, HWAP, Rosetta Stoned). Culling Voices comes from a place that is harder for the audience to connect to, and a genuinely ugly emotion that runs counter to the bigger problem most are dealing with (society-wide reconsideration with the treatment of women for a millennia or two).

Interesting take. I think the song was inspired by his experience, But speaks to the larger phenomena of "cancel culture" writ large. And I don't think it's an ugly emotion and I don't think it runs counter to #metoo either.

I think he might be saying he's changed his perspective about the whole thing since he was accused.

"Psychopathy Misleading me over and over"

Because he knows he is innocent, he now has to question all the other allegations about others. And maybe not taking issue with the idea of holding bad actors accountable, but criticizing the method in which it's been done, in the court of public opinion.

"Judge, condemn, and banish any and everyone Without evidence Only the whispers from within"

I think this puts him more in line with someone like Dave Chappelle...both clearly hold more left leaning views, but have been publicly eviscerated by misguided purity tests which have been truly hobbling the left.

Even the phrase "culling voices" itself seems to point that way. A comic or a director or an actor has some comment they made in an interview 20 years prior bubble up to the surface and it doesn't fit into today's very narrow lane of acceptability, Now we discard their entire body of work.

Yeah, I don't think Maynard is just singing about himself here. He's singing about how something that happened to him changed his perspective regarding the whole thing.

the problem with Culling Voices is it comes from bad inspiration. Don’t want to quibble about song structure or anything - the roots are just bad. A false accusation of sexual assault was thrown at Maynard, and the song comes from resentment. I understand his individual feelings on it, but the inspiration behind tool songs like Pneuma, Schism, and 46&2 is generally far broader that individual experiences. When songs are about a specific issue for a specific individual, they are either from pure motivation (10,000 Days, Jambi) or comically base (Stinkfist, HWAP, Rosetta Stoned). Culling Voices comes from a place that is harder for the audience to connect to, and a genuinely ugly emotion that runs counter to the bigger problem most are dealing with (society-wide reconsideration with the treatment of women for a millennia or two). As such it misses on multiple dimensions, where most other Tool songs connect on multiple dimensions.

I enjoy the song when I try to put myself in the same headspace. But it is not nearly the peer of other songs on FI that are broader in scope and inspiration.

https://seo-service-provider-bd.com/b...