Scott Peterson Case UPDATE: Will the Judge Allow More DNA Testing? State Pushes Back...

Описание: 🧬 SCOTT PETERSON DNA TESTING UPDATE: STATE PUSHES BACK

In this episode, we break down the State’s formal opposition to renewed DNA testing — and the Los Angeles Innocence Project’s reply.

Over the past few weeks, major filings have reshaped the legal fight over whether key physical evidence in the Scott Peterson case should be tested.

⚖️ What’s Happening Now

On January 5, 2026, the Stanislaus County District Attorney’s Office filed an opposition to LAIP’s renewed motion for post-conviction DNA testing under Penal Code §1405.

The State argues:

• Peterson is not entitled to “endless opportunities”
• The motion is procedurally barred
• There is no “new evidence”
• The orange van evidence was destroyed
• The request violates Marsy’s Law

On January 9, 2026, LAIP filed its reply — pushing back on each of those claims.

🧬 What LAIP Argues

The Innocence Project maintains:

• Newly developed scientific evidence contradicts the original timeline presented at trial.
• Updated water modeling suggests Laci’s remains were likely placed near Albany Bulb — not where Peterson fished.
• Police destroyed videotaped burglary interviews shortly after Peterson’s arraignment.
• Penal Code §1405 explicitly allows renewed DNA motions when new evidence emerges.

They are asking the court to allow testing of:

• The Target Bag and duct tape recovered near Laci’s remains
• Items from the burned orange van

🚨 The Orange Van Dispute

One of the biggest issues: the State claims the orange van was destroyed — but has produced no documentation showing when, how, or by whom.

If the van still exists — or was improperly destroyed — that raises serious evidentiary questions.

🔎 Why This Matters

The judge must now decide:

🧬 Should additional DNA testing move forward?
🧬 Is this motion legally barred — or supported by new evidence?

The outcome could determine whether further forensic testing is allowed in one of the most debated murder cases in modern history

Why This Case Matters: The Scott Peterson case has been one of the most polarizing true crime cases in modern history. For many, Scott’s guilt seemed obvious — the cheating husband with motive and opportunity. But as this petition shows, the case is far more complex. If evidence was hidden, destroyed, or misrepresented, it doesn’t just affect Scott — it undermines the entire integrity of the justice system. And if the wrong person has been imprisoned for over 20 years, that means the real killer may still be free. On August 4, 2025, the LAIP filed a massive habeas corpus petition in San Mateo County Superior Court. This petition contains 14 detailed claims, replacing earlier filings from the California Court of Appeal. The petition alleges that Scott Peterson did not receive a fair trial due to police and prosecutorial misconduct, including:

🚨Withholding exculpatory evidence that could have helped the defense 🚨Destroying critical evidence shortly after Scott’s arraignment
🚨Presenting false testimony about eyewitness sightings and timelines
🚨Using outdated scientifically unreliable methods (dog scent tracking)
🚨Failing to disclose alternate suspect leads, including burglary info
🚨The petition also includes cutting-edge scientific evidence:
🚨Fetal development analysis showing that Conner may have lived days longer than prosecutors claimed which destroys prosecution's timeline
🚨Sophisticated water modeling that undermines the theory that Scott dumped the bodies from his small fishing boat.

#ScottPeterson #LAInnocenceProject #DNAEvidence #TrueCrime #JusticeForLaciAndConner #WrongfulConviction #ForensicScience #PostConvictionDNA #CaliforniaJustice #codis