PDPC Rulings: Nullification of Data Access Rights and Systemic Governance Failure
Автор: Ray Lim
Загружено: 2025-11-05
Просмотров: 80
Описание:
This legal discussion analyzes the Personal Data Protection Commission (PDPC) decisions (MCST 4599/3615) which found "no breach" following the auto-deletion of personal data (CCTV footage) during a live Section 21 access request. The video exposes a systemic failure rooted in the following legal flaws:
1. Statutory Loophole: The narrow application of Section 22A creates a "pre-refusal gap," allowing routine data deletion to defeat access rights by circumventing preservation duties. This contradicts Ministerial assurances that the PDPA mandates preservation during processing.
2. Enforcement Failure: The PDPC improperly declined to enforce mandatory preservation obligations under Section 24 (Protection) and Section 25 (Retention Limitation, where a live request constitutes a "legal purpose").
3. Outsourced Accountability: The PDPC excused its inaction by relying on the non-statutory "referral to police" advisory, effectively outsourcing its statutory duty, a procedural deflection later endorsed by IMDA as "according to protocol".
The case demonstrates that procedural compliance was used to obscure accountability, rendering the citizen's right of access "hollow in practice".
Повторяем попытку...
Доступные форматы для скачивания:
Скачать видео
-
Информация по загрузке:
![Как сжимаются изображения? [46 МБ ↘↘ 4,07 МБ] JPEG в деталях](https://image.4k-video.ru/id-video/Kv1Hiv3ox8I)
