What Is the Issue With Italian Films/TV?

Описание: I’m honestly fed up with the Italian film and television system. Every year, we see the same thing: mediocre productions dressed up and glorified as if they were masterpieces. The latest example? They Killed Spider-Man (Hanno ucciso l’Uomo Ragno), a biographical TV drama about the iconic Italian band 883. It was produced by Sky and financed by the Italian Government...

The press in Italy has been showering it with praise: ratings over 8, reviews calling it “a masterpiece of writing,” even Vanity Fair Italy claiming it will “conquer everyone.” But when you actually sit down and watch it, what you get is one of the clearest examples of everything wrong with Italian storytelling today.

In this video, I analyze an entire episode, scene by scene. What I found is shocking: characters constantly sitting or standing still and just talking. No action. No movement. No conflict. Even the rehearsal and the big climactic concert, moments that should be emotional, cathartic, and dynamic, end up flat and anti-climactic. Why? Because in cinema, motion is emotion. Without action tied to character, dialogue loses all weight.

This isn’t just about one series. It’s about a bigger problem with the Italian film industry: a system that rewards passivity on screen, where critics and audiences are encouraged to celebrate static stories that barely use the tools of visual storytelling. Italian TV and film could be bold, alive, full of conflict and movement, but too often, what we get are static conversations disguised as drama.
If you’re interested in film analysis, screenwriting, or just want to understand why Italian cinema struggles compared to international standards, this breakdown of They Killed Spider-Man is for you. Because until the industry realizes that stories live in action, Italian productions will keep talking — but saying very little.

Films used as case studies:

They Killed Spider-Man (2024 - )
Directed by: Sydney Sibilia, Alice Filippi, Francesco Capaldo
Written by: Sydney Sibilia, Francesco Agostini, Chiara Laudani, Giorgio Nerone
Stars: Elia Nuzzolo, Matteo Oscar Giuggioli, Davide Calgaro

A Complete Unknown (2024)
Director: James Mangold
Writers: James Mangold, Jay Cocks, Elijah Wald
Stars: Timothée Chalamet, Edward Norton, Elle Fanning

Theme Music and audio mix by:
   / dk8moore  

His Instagram:
  / denisron.keys  

My Instagram:
  / italianscreenwriter  

My X:
https://x.com/alexvskira

#883 #tvshow #acompleteunknown #screenwriting #TV #Sky #MovieAnalysis #CharacterArc #FilmBreakdown #FilmDiscussion #MovieExplained #filmanalysis #script