Is the LDS Family Proclamation Doctrine or Commentary? A Scholar Explains (Part 1)

Описание: As the Family Proclamation to the World reaches its 30-year anniversary, long-simmering questions about its authority, meaning, and status inside the LDS Church have resurfaced with renewed urgency.

In Part I of this two-part series, therapist and host Valerie is joined by returned guest scholar Dr. Taylor Petrey to examine a central question many Latter-day Saints quietly wrestle with:

Is the Family Proclamation revelation, unchanging doctrine… or something else entirely?

This conversation centers on Taylor’s widely discussed Salt Lake Tribune opinion piece arguing that the Family Proclamation is best understood as commentary rather than revelation or eternal doctrine, a framing that sparked intense backlash from conservative church members and reignited debates about authority, interpretation, and change within Mormonism.

Together, Valerie and Taylor explore how the LDS Church has historically used and shifted categories like doctrine, revelation, policy, and commentary, and why these distinctions matter deeply for members navigating faith, gender, sexuality, and belonging.

In this episode, you’ll hear:
-Why the Family Proclamation is being revisited now, 30 years later
-How proclamations function historically in LDS theology
-Why calling the document “commentary” triggered such strong reactions
-The cultural and political context surrounding the Proclamation’s creation
-How church leaders reinterpret authoritative texts over time

Why “unchanging doctrine” often clashes with lived church history

Rather than attacking the Proclamation, this episode situates it within a larger religious, cultural, and political movement, offering a framework that allows for historical honesty, theological nuance, and ongoing interpretation.

This conversation is especially relevant for:
-Latter-day Saints questioning how doctrine actually works
-Mixed-faith families and LGBTQ+ members impacted by the Proclamation
-Scholars, therapists, and thoughtful believers navigating faith development
-Anyone trying to reconcile authority, revelation, and change inside high-demand religion

📌 This episode sets the stage for Part II, where Valerie and Taylor dive deeper into how the Proclamation has been reinterpreted over time — and why those shifts matter for the future of the Church.

💛 Need More Support for Your Faith Expansion?
Explore curated podcast episodes, free resources, and guidance from Valerie at:
👉 valeriehamaker.com

💛 Enroll in Friday Fellowship:
Access every podcast episode ever recorded, join Valerie in live Office Hours discussions, and gain access to additional healing resources and offerings.
👉https://valeriehamaker.com/podcast-su...

An LDS therapist's thoughtful perspective on navigating the authentic faith journey.
A resource for those who are and those who love others working through challenging issues within the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
This podcast discusses some of the issues caused by traditions in the LDS church.. Valerie is a member of the church and a clinical therapist and bravely breaks down controversial, challenging, and important topics that affects her clients. She questions anything that seems to cause shame, suffering, and struggles for individuals and families.

Resources, blog, shop, scholarships: www.valeriehamaker.com
Instagram:   / latterdaystrugglespodcast