Jordan Peterson & Tim Keller: Two Visions of identity and meaning

Описание: 🎥 We Need to Talk About Hierarchy: Jordan Peterson, Tim Keller, and Jacob’s Ladder

What happens when you fall—and no longer have the strength to climb?

In this video we explore a striking juxtaposition: Jordan Peterson's existential interpretation of Jacob’s ladder from Genesis 28, and Timothy Keller’s gospel-centered reading of the same passage. One sees the ladder as the call to ascend—through moral striving, order, and responsibility. The other sees it as the architecture of grace—a vision of a God who descends.

Drawing on two remarkable talks—Peterson’s conversation with John Vervaeke and Jordan Hall, and Keller’s 2001 sermon “The Openness of Heaven”—we investigate what these two thinkers reveal not only about the biblical text, but about two profoundly different understandings of human nature, morality, hope, and the shape of ultimate reality.

📌 In this video, we reflect on:
Why hierarchy is such a powerful—and dangerous—metaphor for the moral life
How Peterson’s vision of truth, responsibility, and ascent has given meaning to many adrift in a chaotic world
Why Keller’s vision of grace, descent, and divine initiative might offer a deeper, more stable foundation
The psychological, theological, and existential implications of trying to “earn” your meaning
How the Bible overturns every worldly ladder—moral, social, and spiritual—by proclaiming a God who comes down

This is not just a theological debate—it’s a deeply human question: Are we meant to climb our way to wholeness? Or are we meant to be carried, even when we cannot climb?

Whether you’re a Peterson enthusiast, a Keller admirer, or just someone thinking seriously about meaning and morality, you’re warmly invited into this thoughtful exploration.

📖 “Surely the Lord is in this place, and I was not aware of it.” — Genesis 28:16

[00:00] Introduction to the video's theme: hierarchy and its impact on our worldview
[00:16] Setting the scene for Jacob's ladder in Genesis 28
[04:16] Reading of Genesis 28:10-22
[08:10] Jordan Peterson's interpretation of Jacob's ladder
[14:45] Peterson's view on hierarchies and their role in human existence
[16:30] The concept of high and low in Peterson's thinking
[19:19] Peterson's perspective on the political left and right regarding hierarchies
[24:07] The pervasive influence of hierarchies in our lives
[33:11] Timothy Keller's interpretation of Jacob's ladder
[39:31] Comparison of Peterson's and Keller's views on the meaning of life and moral ascent
[43:05] The consequences of building life on ascent, according to Keller
[53:50] Keller's perspective on sin and atonement
[58:39] Jesus's use of the image of Jacob's ladder in the New Testament
[01:03:03] Keller's view on God's interaction with worldly hierarchies
[01:13:44] The concept of subversive fulfillment in the Bible
[01:14:25] The role of the cross in Keller's theology
[01:26:04] Peterson's implicit reliance on concepts that Keller explicitly addresses
[01:34:32] The contrasting roles of the individual and Christ in Peterson's and Keller's narratives
[01:35:50] Conclusion and reflection on the question of "What happens when you fall?"
[01:43:00] Final thoughts on Jacob's story and the message of grace

#JordanPeterson #TimKeller #JacobsLadder #Genesis28 #Christianity #Grace #Hierarchy #Theology #Philosophy #FaithAndCulture #MoralLife #Gospel