Google Vids vs Canva Video and WeVideo

Описание: Edtech Throwdown


Episode 206: Google Vids vs Canva Video and WeVideo






Welcome to the EdTech Throwdown.  This is episode 206 called “Google Vids vs Canva Video and WeVideo”  In this episode, we’ll talk about a new-ish Google app called Google Vids and how it stacks up against other popular classroom video creation tools.  This is another episode you don’t want to miss.  Check it out.
Segment 1: What is Google Vids?






Narrative: Have we ever solved the problem of fast and easy screencasts?  A teacher asked me that this week and I realized I didn’t have a great answer.


ScreenPal has an extension, but the increased tools make it slower


WeVideo has an extension, but it is clunky and not free


Screencastify still exists, but have to pay after 10 videos






Released:  Google Vids was first announced and released in preview during Google Cloud Next in April 2024, with a wider rollout to all Google Workspace users starting in November 2024 as an AI-powered video creation tool for work. 






What is it?  It is a video editing platform that feels more like creating a Google Slide than a video editing platform.  Is this a positive thing … not sure yet.






Free Basic Version: All users get access to the web-based editor, allowing recording, importing clips, using templates, and basic editing. 






AI Extras (Paid): Advanced AI tools, such as AI-generated clips from prompts, AI avatars, and enhanced script/outline generation, require paid Google Workspace or AI plan subscriptions. 






What can it do?

• Screen records with or without webcam
• Converts slides to video
• Upload your own photos and videos for editing
• Has video templates with title slides, animations, etc.
• Multiple layouts: landscape, portrait, square
• Has stock audio from Youtube audio library - good music!
• Has most, if not all, typical video editing tools: playhead, video preview, splitting, multiple track editing, etc.






Benefits:

• Integration: Works directly within the Google ecosystem, integrating with Google Drive for easy access to files. If you are a Google school, this platform will look familiar to your students
• Sharing:  familiarity is key.  You can share you vids projects just like a doc or slide.  We tested simultaneous editing, it works well
• Relatively simple to use.  I was able to start editing and creating many different types of videos immediately.
• Downloads are very simple, better than the WeVideo we use with Ss now






What Can’t it Do:

• 10 minute time limit - this is a big one
• "Slideshow" Nature: The primary criticism is that Google Vids is essentially an AI-assisted presentation or slideshow creator, not a full-fledged, cinematic video generation tool. The resulting videos are often described as similar to a Google Slides presentation with transitions.
• Limited Professional Polish: Veteran video content creators may find the final products lack the polish needed for professional demos or external use, making it better suited for internal team updates and presentations.
• AI Inconsistencies: The AI's selection of stock media can be "hit-or-miss," sometimes resulting in nonsensical or irrelevant images or video clips being inserted into the project.
• Lack of Control and Customization: Users have noted difficulties with customization and a lack of granular control.
• Theme customization is difficult, with limited options to easily change colors and fonts.
• Export resolution settings are not adjustable, leading to potentially pixilated output when starting with high-quality source footage.
• Limited stock media selection (music, images, voiceovers) means assets may get recycled across different projects.








Segment 2: How does it compare to others?










What we think:





1. As a tool for fast and easy classroom video creation:
2. Nick thinks… Vids!  Or Canva if I want it to be social media-ish
3. Guise thinks…
4. As a tool for complex video editing:
5. Nick thinks … WeVideo (we already pay for it), Vids if we didn’t pay for it
6. Guise thinks …
7. As a tool for teacher screencasting:
8. Nick thinks … ScreenPal because I pay for it, Vids if I didn’t
9. Guise thinks … 
10. As a tool for professional or social media style videos:
11. Nick thinks …Canva
12. Guise thinks …
13. Will we use Google Vids over other tools like ScreenPal, WeVideo or Screencastify?
14. Nick thinks … No, but if and when we don’t have paid tools, YES
15. Guise thinks …
16. Which tool fits with state of tech in schools today?
17. See the table






Edtech Throwdown: 






Vote on twitter @edtechthrowdown and under the pinned post on the profile.




Segment 3: Where to Find EdTech Throwdown






Do us a few favors:

1. Subscribe to the Edtech Throwdown Podcast
2. Apple Podcasts (https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/g...)
3. Spotify (https://open.spotify.com/show/7zyzf...