Is Hadith Shariyat/Responding to Javaid gamdhi's Meezan, Part 2
Автор: THE STRAIGHT PATH (القران الكريم)
Загружено: 2026-01-20
Просмотров: 10
Описание:
In this second part, we dive deeper into the foundational claims made by Javaid Ahmad Ghamidi in his book Meezan. We specifically analyze his argument that the Sunnah is merely an extension of the "Religion of Ibrahim" (Ibrahimic Shariat) and provide a point-by-point refutation based on the Quran and Classical Tafsir.
Key Arguments Covered:
The Context of "Follow the Religion of Ibrahim": Why Surah An-Nahl (16:123) refers to Aqidah (Tawheed) rather than a continuation of Ibrahimic law [01:04].
Independent Shariat: Using Surah Al-Ma'idah (5:48) to prove that every Messenger was given a unique law and method [03:00].
The Scholarly View: Insights from Imam Qurtabi and Abu Hayyan’s Bahr al-Muhit regarding the distinction between universal Deen and specific Shariat [03:46].
Rasul vs. Nabi: Why the "Meezan" framework creates a logical contradiction regarding the status of Prophet Muhammad (ﷺ) [06:25].
The Miraj Proof: A powerful logical argument: If the Prophet (ﷺ) was following the Ibrahimic law, why did he take counsel from Prophet Musa (AS) regarding the prayer during the Night Journey? [07:17].
Sources Mentioned:
Meezan by Javaid Ahmad Ghamidi
Bahr al-Muhit by Abu Hayyan
Imam Qurtabi
Sahih Ibn Hibban
Stay connected to THE STRAIGHT PATH for more evidence-based refutations. Subscribe and hit the bell icon for Part 3.
#GhamidiRefutation #Meezan #IslamicScholarship #Hadith #Shariat #TheStraightPath
Повторяем попытку...
Доступные форматы для скачивания:
Скачать видео
-
Информация по загрузке:
