Geopolitics, Conflict & Shifting Alliances Reshaping Global Critical Minerals Supply & And Outlook

Описание: London Indaba 2024 - Day 1

Featuring:
Chair: Henk de Hoop, CEO, SFA Oxford
Tim Gould, Chief Economist, International Energy Agency
Paul Gait, Group Head of Strategy, Anglo American
Veronica Bolton-Smith, Africa Advisor, Critical Minerals International Alliance

Moderator Hank, joined by experts from the IEA, Anglo American, and the Critical Minerals Association, dissects the geopolitical battleground for resources.

The panel analyzes China's 30-year strategic head start in EV supply chains, Africa's dual role as a critical supplier and underserved demand center, and whether Western companies can compete against state-backed capital and different risk appetites.

Timestamps:
00:13 Introductory Remarks: China's 30-Year Head Start in EVs
02:57 IEA Report: Africa's Role in Critical Mineral Scenarios
04:19 The Concentration of Clean Energy Investment (China/Advanced Economies)
07:25 Anglo American's Strategy: Competing with Chinese and Middle Eastern Capital
10:47 The Loss of "Animal Spirits" and Risk Appetite in Western Mining
12:21 Government Demands: Beneficiation and Downstream Processing
15:38 The Minerals Security Partnership: Excluding Africa from the Table
16:16 Geopolitics: The Danger of "Beggar Thy Neighbor" Policies
19:04 Rising Capital Intensity: The Billion-Dollar Project Problem
22:10 Success Factors: Governance, Institutions, and Market Proximity
23:21 Subsidies War: China ($230B) vs. US IRA ($300B) vs. Saudi ($1T)
25:37 Capital Allocation: Diverting Trillions to Entertainment vs. Industry
28:30 The Failure of Nationalization: Mexico, Panama, and Historical Precedent
30:51 Oil Market Outlook: Peak Demand and Spare Capacity Risks
36:54 Nuclear Energy and Uranium: Essential for 2050 Goals
37:51 The Reality of Sanctions: Russian PGM Flows to China
39:48 M&A Debate: Does Consolidation Create Wealth or Just Rearrange Claims?

Key Takeaways:

China's Unassailable Head Start:
China's strategic focus on electric mobility began in its 1991 Five-Year Plan. Decades of building integrated capabilities—from parts manufacturing to Gigafactory construction and global shipping—have created a vertically integrated EV powerhouse that is "very difficult to compete with."

The Capital vs. Competitiveness Conundrum:
While abundant capital exists, Western risk aversion and high required IRRs are a form of "choosing not to compete." As Paul from Anglo American notes, competitors are "hungrier, have a greater tolerance for failure, and act more quickly." The industry has lost its "animal spirit."

Africa's Dual Reality & The MSP Gap:
Africa holds 60% of the world's best solar resources but only 1% of installed PV capacity. It is poised to supply 30% of the world's critical minerals yet has zero representation in the Western-led Minerals Security Partnership (MSP). Jeff Townsend states bluntly: "If you don't give someone a voice, they're not gonna listen."

The Copper Imperative:
The math is categorical. Providing a Western standard of living requires ~250kg of copper per person. For 2 billion new people, that's 500 million tons of copper—roughly 25 years of the entire industry's current output, before adding green energy demands. The IEA confirms copper faces the single biggest supply shortfall.

Collaboration Over Confrontation:
A repeated theme is that adversarial, "beggar-thy-neighbour" approaches or dividing the world into "good and naughty lists" will sterilize deposits and lower global growth. The scale of capital required (e.g., copper projects now costing $8-10B) necessitates partnerships and joint ventures to de-risk.

Value Addition:
A Realistic Conversation: The panel argues for honest dialogue with host governments: midstream processing must align with commercial logic, not political mandate. The UK's chemical industry strength, for example, makes it a logical location for certain refining steps, while simpler processing should be done in-country.

The False Promise of Consolidation:
Hank and the panel conclude that consolidation does not solve physical supply shortages. "You cannot consolidate yourself into additional copper supply." True wealth creation comes from building new productive capacity, not financially re-bundling existing assets.

Note on Timestamps:
Timestamps are linked to key discussion points and may begin a few seconds before each segment for contextual continuity.

Subscribe to our other platforms and keep the conversations going:

The Zero Bull Sh*t Newsletter:
  / zero-bull-sht-7312489607210635266  

THINKspiration:
  / thinkspiration  

Resources For Africa:
  / resources-for-africa