Vatican II and Religious Liberty w/ Professor Michael Dunnigan

Описание: Vatican II and Religious Liberty w/ Professor Michael Dunnigan

Professor Michael Dunnigan addresses the question of religious liberty in the pre-conciliar popes and compares it to the Second Vatican Council. He demonstrates how to apply the hermeneutic of continuity and show that the popes and the council were not diametrically opposed but can be harmonized.

[00:00:00] - Show Intro & Guest Welcome
[00:01:12] - Hermeneutic of Continuity
[00:02:46] - Continuity vs. Rupture
[00:10:02] - Historical Church-State Dynamics
[00:16:21] - Gallican Dualism & Its Roots
[00:20:01] - Collaboration vs. Separation
[00:25:10] - Preconciliar Popes on Religious Liberty
[00:29:03] - Revolutionary Rights & Natural Law
[00:33:06] - Unlimited Religious Rights
[00:37:07] - Preconciliar vs. Vatican II on Religious Liberty
[00:38:19] - Unlimited Rights & French Declaration Articles
[00:40:12] - "Within Due Limits" in Vatican II
[00:43:09] - Right as an Immunity
[00:44:27] - Catholic vs. Secular Models
[00:46:05] - The State’s Incompetence in Religious Matters
[00:49:04] - Advocating Human Dignity as the Foundation
[00:51:05] - Limitations of State Incompetence Argument
[01:00:07] - Free Will, Truth, and Religious Duty
[01:04:07] - Draft Clarifications & "Ratio" Nuances
[01:05:07] - Distinguishing Draft Variants: May 1965 Ratio
[01:06:07] - Reflecting on Vatican II’s Reception
[01:08:35] - Scholarly Engagement & Criticism of Dignitatum
[01:12:26] - Emphasizing Human Integrity in Religious Liberty
[01:14:03] - Navigating Dissent & Hierarchical Authority
[01:16:59] - Exsurge Domine & the Death Penalty Debate
[01:19:09] - Unpacking Leo X’s Bull on Burning Heretics
[01:23:04] - Confirming Interpretations & Future Implications

📖Answering Orthodoxy: https://shop.catholic.com/answering-o...
🎓Courses: https://www.rtcourses.com/
💰Go Fund Me: https://gofund.me/e12bf94e
💰Donate: https://www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted...
👪Patreon: patreon.com/reasonandtheology
Facebook:   / themichaelloftonshowrt  
Store: https://rtmerchstore.com/
Twitter: https://x.com/ReasonTheology

DON'T FORGET TO SUBSCRIBE AND LIKE!