How Should a Society Pick Its Judges? | Debater Duel

Описание: Should justice be decided at the ballot box or behind closed doors?

In this thought-provoking Debater Duel, Asians Quarterfinalist David Mencias and Asians Double Octofinalist Namita Pandey face off on the motion: “This House prefers appointed to elected judges.”

Info Slide:
In most countries judges are appointed. In other countries, such as the US, Japan, and Switzerland, some judges are elected. The methods and voting systems used to elect these judges vary based on country and municipality.

This debate explores fairness, independence, and accountability in the justice system:
• Do appointed judges better protect judicial independence and expertise?
• Or do elected judges ensure democratic accountability and public trust?

A must-watch for debaters, students, and anyone interested in law, democracy, and governance.

--

Debater Duel by EduDrift is a showcase of high-level competitive debates between some of the best speakers across the global circuit. Each episode features a one-on-one clash on urgent, controversial, and thought-provoking motions—ranging from politics and ethics to science, education, and social values.

Designed as both a training tool and a platform for public discourse, Debater Duel spotlights: (1) World-class debaters from major tournaments like Worlds, Australasians, and Asians, (2) motions grounded in real-world issues and policy debates, and (3) a balance of clash, nuance, and strategic framing.

Whether you're a student, coach, or lifelong learner, this series offers a front-row seat to arguments that matter. Use it to sharpen your adjudication, expand your topic knowledge, or explore the future of public reasoning.
New rounds are released regularly. Subscribe to EduDrift for more debates, training content, and global discourse at its finest.

Disclaimer: The information in this video is provided on an “as is” basis. This information presented was produced and collected by EduDrift as of the date of writing and is subject to change. It has been prepared solely for information purposes for the delivery of a demonstration debate on the abovementioned topic. EduDrift or any of its affiliates makes no representation or warranty, either expressed or implied, as to the accuracy or completeness of the information in the video and shall not be liable for any loss arising from the use hereof. Views expressed within the content do not necessarily reflect the views and opinions of EduDrift or of the speaker