PU FAIZ CABAR WAN SYUKRI: TUNJUKKAN SEORANG SALAF KATA MALAIKAT DI BAWAH ALLAH!

Описание: Dalam video ini, PU Faiz mengulas hujah Wan Syukri dalam debat bersama Dr Aman, khususnya dakwaan bahawa ayat “يَخَافُونَ رَبَّهُم مِّن فَوْقِهِمْ” bermaksud malaikat berada “di bawah Allah” secara arah. Ulasan ini menegaskan bahawa tafsiran tersebut bercanggah dengan manhaj Salaf kerana menambah makna yang tidak dinyatakan oleh nas, serta bertentangan dengan ayat al-Qur’an dan hadith sahih yang menafikan konsep arah dan tempat bagi Allah.

This video is intended solely for educational and academic critique. It examines statements made by Wan Syukri in the recent debate, particularly his claim that the Qur’anic verse implies angels are “below Allah” in a directional sense.

Through a close reading of the relevant verses, prophetic hadith, and the established methodology of the Salaf, this presentation highlights fundamental errors in textual interpretation, including adding meanings not stated by the text and departing from the principle of accepting the wording as it came (imrāruhā kamā jā’at).

By referencing authoritative sources, this video demonstrates that such interpretations are not supported by the Salaf, nor by the classical understanding of Allah’s attributes, and that they contradict clear prophetic narrations affirming that nothing is above or below Allah.

The discussion is purely scholarly in nature and aims to clarify methodology, not to engage in personal attacks. Viewers are encouraged to examine the cited texts carefully, verify the references, and approach matters of creed with precision, responsibility, and adherence to the classical tradition.