Fixing the SortedSet Insertion Issue in C# Pathfinding Algorithms

Описание: Learn how to solve the `SortedSet` insertion issue when working with pathfinding algorithms in C# . This guide will provide you with essential tips for correctly managing node comparisons to ensure proper sorting.
---
This video is based on the question https://stackoverflow.com/q/64806487/ asked by the user 'Celeste Soueid' ( https://stackoverflow.com/u/12810598/ ) and on the answer https://stackoverflow.com/a/64818744/ provided by the user 'Celeste Soueid' ( https://stackoverflow.com/u/12810598/ ) at 'Stack Overflow' website. Thanks to these great users and Stackexchange community for their contributions.

Visit these links for original content and any more details, such as alternate solutions, latest updates/developments on topic, comments, revision history etc. For example, the original title of the Question was: SortedSet inserting element out of sort

Also, Content (except music) licensed under CC BY-SA https://meta.stackexchange.com/help/l...
The original Question post is licensed under the 'CC BY-SA 4.0' ( https://creativecommons.org/licenses/... ) license, and the original Answer post is licensed under the 'CC BY-SA 4.0' ( https://creativecommons.org/licenses/... ) license.

If anything seems off to you, please feel free to write me at vlogize [AT] gmail [DOT] com.
---
Solving the SortedSet Insertion Issue in C# Pathfinding

When working on pathfinding algorithms, we often encounter scenarios where efficient sorting of nodes is crucial for performance. A common problem that may arise is that elements, specifically nodes, can be incorrectly inserted into a SortedSet, resulting in unexpected behaviors. This blog will delve into a recent challenge I faced involving a SortedSet in C# , which led to out-of-order insertions when sorting nodes by their evaluation score. We'll explore the issue in detail and break down the solution to help you avoid similar pitfalls in your implementations.

The Problem: Out-of-Order Insertions in SortedSet

In this specific situation, the issue occurred when nodes, sorted by their F-score, would occasionally appear at the minimum value position in the SortedSet even when they should’ve been placed somewhere else. The symptoms included:

Incorrect Node Removal: The incorrect node was considered the lowest priority even after being artificially modified.

Unexpected Loop Behavior: The algorithm execution showed that certain iterations consistently resulted in nodes being incorrectly prioritized.

The trouble originated from an incomplete understanding of the requirements for object comparison in SortedSet collections, which are pivotal for maintaining the correct order.

Understanding the Comparer

Here's the Comparer used in managing node comparisons:

[[See Video to Reveal this Text or Code Snippet]]

In this implementation, each Node is compared based first on its F score, and then on the G score if necessary. This makes it important to note that any changes made to the properties affecting these comparisons can lead to the SortedSet behaving unexpectedly.

The Core of the Issue

The main reason for the improper insertion lies in how updates are made to the Node properties after they are added to the SortedSet. If a node is modified while it's still part of the set, it can lead to scenarios where:

The sorted position in the tree becomes invalid.

The SortedSet fails to ensure the order correctly, which leads to it being perceived as having the wrong lowest value.

Previous Code Snippet Causing Issues

The specific code leading to these difficulties was as follows:

[[See Video to Reveal this Text or Code Snippet]]

Key Takeaways for Comparison

Removal Before Modification: SortedSet requires that if you modify a node's critical properties affecting its sorted position, the node must first be removed from the set, modified, and then re-added. This ensures the SortedSet can maintain its structure correctly.

Implementing the Solution

To resolve the issue, I restructured the problematic code in a way that ensured nodes are removed before any property modifications are made. The revised code looks like this:

[[See Video to Reveal this Text or Code Snippet]]

Breakdown of Changes

Condition Check: The program first checks if the neighbor has been opened and removes it only if necessary.

Modification of Properties: After ensuring the neighbor is cleared from the set, properties are updated without the risk of influencing the set's order.

Re-Addition: The node is then added back to the SortedSet, maintaining the correct order.

Conclusion

By gaining a better understanding of how SortedSet operates in conjunction with custom comparers, we can avoid subtle but critical errors when managing collections of objects that need to be sorted. Always remember that modifications to objects in a sorted collection require careful handling to prevent inconsistencies. With these tips, you’ll be better prepared to implement robust C# pathfinding algorithms that oper