Was Jesus Really a Muslim? The Evidence Most Debates Ignore

Описание: Was Jesus a Muslim?

This claim appears frequently in modern Islamic apologetics. The argument suggests that because Islam means “submission to God,” anyone who submitted to God — including Jesus — must therefore be considered Muslim.

But is that claim historically accurate?

In this documentary, we examine:

• The definition of “Muslim” in Islamic theology
• The chronological gap between Jesus and Islam
• The historical context of first-century Judea
• Primary source analysis from early Islamic texts
• Sahih al-Bukhari 5134 and Sahih Muslim 1422b
• The narration of Aisha’s age and classical commentary
• The dolls narration in Sahih al-Bukhari 6130
• Classical scholarly acceptance vs modern reinterpretation
• Comparative legal norms in Byzantine and rabbinic law
• The question of historical consistency

This is not an emotional argument.

It is a methodological one.

If modern religious definitions can be applied retroactively to Jesus, then modern legal definitions must also be applied consistently to historical figures within Islam.

Either context governs history — or it does not.

This documentary explores that tension carefully, logically, and symmetrically.

Sources referenced include:

• Sahih al-Bukhari 5134
• Sahih al-Bukhari 6130
• Sahih Muslim 1422b
• Fath al-Bari (Ibn Hajar commentary)
• Roman and Byzantine legal marriage thresholds
• Rabbinic legal maturity discussions (Niddah 46a)

This video is intended for serious discussion and open debate.

Respectful dialogue is welcome.