Why Your Average Return Is a Lie (Volatility Drag Explained)
Автор: Money Bloom
Загружено: 2026-08-23
Просмотров: 175
Описание:
A fund quotes a 10% average return. Up 50% one year, down 50% the next — the average says you broke even. You are down 25%.
That gap, between the average return everyone quotes and the rate money actually compounds at, is volatility drag: the whole difference between an average return and a CAGR. We build it from scratch — arithmetic versus geometric mean, the approximation geometric ≈ arithmetic − σ²/2, what it does to anything wobbly (including holding a leveraged ETF long term, where the daily reset bites) — then test it on 99 years of US market data.
And we are honest about the part most explainers skip: nothing is subtracted, there is no force. Arithmetic above geometric is an identity, true of any series that varies — and σ²/2 only approximates it, overstating the drag.
CHAPTERS
0:00 A 10% average, and the 25% you actually lost
0:46 Two averages: the quoted one, and the one your money obeys
1:42 No force, no theft — the honest version of "drag"
2:22 The equation: geometric ≈ arithmetic − σ²/2
3:24 Same 10% average, three different outcomes
3:59 Where the rule breaks: it overstates the drag
5:07 Leveraged ETFs and the daily reset
6:47 The drag runs both ways: 2022
7:36 99 years of real data: 12.19% vs 10.27%
8:16 Smooth is wealth
THE NUMBERS
BASIS A for the 99-year figures: US stock market, total return, dividends reinvested, nominal, value-weighted across all CRSP firms on the NYSE, AMEX or NASDAQ, 1927–2025 (99 calendar years) — Kenneth R. French Data Library, Dartmouth, 202606 CRSP database.
• Arithmetic average of those 99 returns: 12.19% a year. The rate that compounded: 10.27%. Gap: 1.92 percentage points (σ²/2 gives 1.97 — close, slightly too big).
• $1 became $15,952. Compounding the 12.19% average predicts $88,295 — about 5.5x too high.
• Hold the average at 10% and move only volatility: the rule says 9.5% / 8.0% / 5.5% at 10% / 20% / 30% volatility; the exact math says 9.55% / 8.23% / 6.12%. At 30% you still keep about 61% of your average, not half.
• At 150% volatility the rule predicts −102.5% — losing more than everything you own. The exact answer is about −35%.
• Leverage: 19 Feb to 18 Aug 2020, the Nasdaq-100 tracker returned +17.75% and the 3x fund +14.87% — less than the plain index, over a window in which the index rose, at ~45% index volatility. Since 2011 the 3x fund has come in under three times the tracker in 9 of 15 years.
• It cuts both ways: in 2022 the tracker fell 32.58%; three times that is −97.73%; the fund's own published return was −79.03% — nearly 19 points better, because resetting daily de-risks you into a decline.
• The 50-up-50-down path and the 10% table are illustrations; the video says so. Every dated figure is real.
WHAT THIS VIDEO DOES NOT CLAIM
Not that leveraged funds decay to zero or must lose to the index long term: over 2011–2025 the 3x Nasdaq-100 fund compounded at 39.25% a year against the tracker's 18.56% (daily adjusted closes, a different basis). The narrower claim: a daily-reset fund often delivers less than the multiple it advertises, and the sign of the shortfall depends on the path.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
• Money multiplies, it does not add. The arithmetic average of period returns is not the number that compounds, and quoting it as if it were overstates the wealth ahead of you.
• The gap is driven by the swings, not the average — squared, then halved. Double the volatility and the drag roughly quadruples. But σ²/2 is a rule of thumb: it overstates the drag, and fails on very volatile assets.
• For the same average return, a smoother path compounds into more money — the case for diversification and rebalancing. The literature disagrees on why: variance reduction (Booth & Fama) or the rebalancing trade itself (Willenbrock).
RELATED: "The Just One More Trap" on this channel — the coin flip worth +5% a round that still ruins almost everyone. Same villain, new disguise.
SOURCES
• Kenneth R. French Data Library: https://mba.tuck.dartmouth.edu/pages/...
• ProShares UltraPro QQQ Summary Prospectus, 2025: https://www.proshares.com/globalasset...
• Will Morrison, "The Myth of Volatility Drag" Part 2 (CFA Institute): https://rpc.cfainstitute.org/blogs/en...
• Michael Kitces — why quoted investment returns are already geometric: https://www.kitces.com/blog/volatilit...
NOT FINANCIAL ADVICE. This video is for education only. Not investment or tax advice; nothing here recommends buying, selling or holding any security or fund. Past returns do not predict future returns. Leveraged funds are built for daily objectives and can lose money even when the index they track is flat or rising. Do your own research.
If this changed how you read an average return, subscribe — that's the whole channel.
Money Bloom — finance, economics and math, animated.
Повторяем попытку...
Доступные форматы для скачивания:
Скачать видео
-
Информация по загрузке: