Charting Human and Divine, Substance and Property (Yehuda Halper)
Автор: Medieval Philosophy Unleashed
Загружено: 2024-11-29
Просмотров: 90
Описание:
Yehuda Halper, "Ecce Homo: Charting Human and Divine, Substance and Property, in Contradictory Syllogisms in a Short, Anonymous Text in Three Manuscripts".
Workshop: "Glimpses of the Invisible: Visualising the Principles of Nature Before the Rise of Modernity" 29-29 November 2024.
Abstract: The short text of an anonymous Hebrew commentary on Maimonides’ notion of contradiction contained in three manuscripts consists mainly of two charts visualizing syllogistic inference. Taking nearly identical sets of premises, these charts lead to contradictory conclusions: “Every man is a substance” and “Every man is a proprium.” The visualizations displayed in the charts highlight the similarities in the arguments, especially since they name the premises and point out how they are joined to form conclusions. The method of showing inference is similar in some ways to the Porphyrian trees we find in Hebrew manuscripts. Yet, what is highlighted here is the contradiction between a proprium and a substance. This contradiction is significant because it highlights not only the difficulty Maimonides has in talking about humanity as natural beings, but especially in talking about God in human terms. As such, this short treatise uses an image to point out a central problem in Maimonides’ Guide of the Perplexed and to suggest that overcoming this problem is more complicated than simply interpreting human terms for God as allegorical, but would require a more robust understanding of the proprium / substance distinction. That is, it calls into question Maimonides’ entire philosophical project.
Повторяем попытку...
Доступные форматы для скачивания:
Скачать видео
-
Информация по загрузке: